Old City Express LLC

Interstate
(11 reviews) 4.4 out of 5
1201 Dublin Rd 515 Columbus, OH US 43215
USDOT
2984398
Docket
MC015905

Updated October 12, 2026

Carrier Ratings

Quality of Equipment
8.8
Communication
8.5
Timeliness
8.6

Positive Flags

On Time Delivery
10
On Time Pickup
9
Consistent Tracking
7
Strong Dispatcher Communication
6
Strong Driver Communication
4
Easy to Work With
4
Good Delivery Condition
4
Friendly
1
Easy to Onboard
1
Clean Equipment
1
Knowledgeable
1

Negative Flags

Late Pickup
1
Poor Dispatcher Communication
1
Poor Driver Communication
1
Fraud
1
CarrierSource AI

What would you like to know about Old City Express LLC?

Overview

Old City Express aims to deliver innovative, value-driving supply chain solutions. We pay special attention to the safety of our drivers and hauled cargo, offering 24/7 dispatch services so that you always know your cargo is in qualified hands. We make sure your shipment gets moving, quickly finding reputable drivers to move your goods. Time is money, and we keep our drivers moving so that they’re able to make a great living while providing timely delivery of your cargo

Fleet Details

Type Tractors Trailers Trucks
Owned 29 25 0
Leased 33 38 0

Freight

  • General Freight
  • Metal: Sheets, Coils, Rolls

Truck Types

  • Box Truck
  • Container
  • Dry Van
  • Reefer
  • Flatbed
  • Power Only

Shipment Types

  • Full Truckload
  • Partial Truckload

Specialized Services

  • Drop Trailer
  • Team Drivers
  • Consolidation
  • Drayage
  • Dedicated Fleet
MCS-150 Mileage
5,946,700 (2025)
Electronic Tracking
64% of reviewers say the carrier uses electronic tracking

Compliance

Authorizations

FMCSA authority status
Motor Carrier Active — 11/01/2021 (4 years, 11 months)
Carrier operation
Interstate
Cargo authorization
Property

Safety Violations

Type Total Severe Out of Service Measure Percentile
Vehicle Maintenance 117 24 0 4.82 38.3%
Unsafe Driving 60 16 0 5.33 59.8%
Hours of Service Compliance 24 6 0 0.28 18.4%
Driver Fitness 3 2 0 0.09 7.5%
Controlled Substances 0 0 0 0 0%

Accident Report

Type Last 6 Months 6-12 Months ago 12-24 Months ago Total
Fatalities 0 0 0 0
Injuries 0 3 13 16
Tow-away 0 0 0 0
Crash Reports 0 5 17 22

Inspections

Type Inspections OOS Inspections OOS Percentage National Average
Driver 265 5 1.89% 6.67%
Vehicle 125 34 27.2% 22.26%

Insurance Coverage

Insurance Type
BIPD
Company Name
Universal Casualty Risk Retention Group, Inc
Policy Limit
$750,000
Policy Number
URG04882
Effective Date
05/29/2026

Showing 11 of 11 Reviews Clear Filters
OH

Verified Broker from Ohio

October 03, 2025

“Decent Job”

Timeliness
10/10
Quality of Equipment
10/10
Communication
6/10

What went well?
  • On Time Pickup
  • On Time Delivery
What went poorly?
  • Poor Driver Communication

Old City did well on this run in June, but due to poor driver comms, I would vet more thoroughly for another load. On time, but the updates were not there.


Lanes
Springdale, AR to Sedalia, MO
Freight Details
General Freight
Tracking
Offers electronic tracking
Tracking not functional
NJ

Verified Shipper from New Jersey

July 22, 2025

“No Issues”

Timeliness
9/10
Communication
10/10

What went well?
  • On Time Pickup
  • On Time Delivery

Did not have any issues like stated in one of the other reviews. Our load was not "stolen" and this carrier did a good job for us. On time pick up and delivery.


Lanes
Parkersburg, WV to Dunellen, NJ
Freight Details
General Freight
Tracking
Did not use electronic tracking
BC

Brooks C - Verified Broker

June 25, 2025

“Company has been compromised. Loads being stolen.”

Timeliness
1/10
Quality of Equipment
1/10
Communication
1/10

What went poorly?
  • Fraud

DO NOT USE unless you speak to the number on FMCSA. They have been compromised. Have stolen 5 loads in the past 2-3 weeks, one of ours and 4 others per CargoNet.


Lanes
Kearny, NJ to Jackson, MS
Freight Details
Refrigerated Food
Tracking
Did not use electronic tracking
OH

Verified Broker from Ohio

June 08, 2024

“Full Truckload from Springfield, MO to Capitol Heights, MD”

Timeliness
10/10
Quality of Equipment
10/10
Communication
10/10

What went well?
  • On Time Pickup
  • On Time Delivery
  • Consistent Tracking
  • Strong Dispatcher Communication
  • Strong Driver Communication
  • Easy to Work With
  • Good Delivery Condition

Great team carrier. Team drivers communication was solid and on point also was the dispatchers. Drivers were able to track during the entier haul through macropoint. Very punctual to appointments


Lanes
Springfield, MO to Capitol Heights, MD
Freight Details
General Freight
Tracking
Offers electronic tracking
Tracking functional
IN

Verified Broker from Indiana

June 07, 2024

“Full Truckload from Lima, OH to Salem, VA”

Timeliness
10/10
Quality of Equipment
10/10
Communication
10/10

What went well?
  • On Time Pickup
  • On Time Delivery
  • Consistent Tracking
  • Strong Dispatcher Communication
  • Strong Driver Communication
  • Easy to Work With

On-time pickup and delivery. The driver tracked consistently. The dispatcher was very communicative, provided constant updates, and kept us posted the entire time.


Lanes
Lima, OH to Salem, VA
Freight Details
General Freight
Tracking
Offers electronic tracking
Tracking functional